Which Story Is True?

One of these stories is true.

Someone must live.

Someone must die.

Story 1:

A 32-year-old man in Townsend, NC was arrested today for violently assaulting and kidnapping a 5-year-old girl near the elementary school. The man was pulled over for a traffic violation when law enforcement heard a child's cry coming from his trunk. Searching the vehicle, the little girl was rescued from the back of the vehicle and rushed to the hospital for medical attention and was reunited with her distraught mother. Law enforcement also found a bloody tire iron, a bag of heroin, and a small glitter backpack. The man aggressively denied any connection to the crime saying that he was only trying to "free her from Satan." The perpetrator has been arrested and will stand trial on Wednesday.

Story 2:

A 28-year old mother in Townsend, NC called police dispatch to report her missing 5-year-old daughter. Witnesses reported seeing a gentleman speaking to a little girl fitting the description of the missing child. The child was covered in blood and seemed to be running away from home. Searching the home, police found multiple empty bags and drug paraphenalia. The mother was arrested under the suspicion of abuse against her daughter. The gentleman in question was found when the gentleman dropped off the little girl at a nearby police department. She is now recieving medical care.